Monday, January 7, 2019

Further Away from Homeostasis

Other Unnatural Consequences of Restriction

As we have seen, every time you choose to ignore your hunger, i.e. not feed your body when it requires energy and demands food, you are telling your body there is a famine. All forms of diets do this, even the “light” ones, even the ones that promise you won’t go hungry or claim that you can eat what you want. Do not be fooled: in every diet, there’s always obvious or hidden restrictions. We have seen that restriction leads to binges (eating uncontrollably and excessively) as a compensatory response to the periods of restriction. Binges are nothing but an attempt to break the famine, a strategy we can label as “desperately increasing caloric intake”. Another response to intense or prolonged restriction is to save energy at all costs - it’s a “desperately decreasing caloric expenditure” kind of strategy. Let’s see how it works.

When the body’s energy requirements are not met through adequate food intake (i.e. hunger signals are not followed by feeding), the body looks for alternative sources of energy. The most readily available source is the proteins in your muscles. At the same time as your hungry body begins to break down muscle mass, basal metabolism also starts to shut down in order to decrease energy expenditure. On average, most of the calories you burn in one day is just to keep your organs (heart, brain, kidneys) working at rest - this is called basal metabolism. Only a small portion of the total calories spent are due to physical activity. However, when your body starts going into survival mode and shutting everything down to keep energy loss at a strict minimum, it starts guarding every calorie jealously. It won’t let go of any fat, won’t allow any weight loss, because it’s a matter of survival! With a slower metabolism and less muscle mass, you will burn LESS calories than before, whether at rest or during exercise. You may even notice symptoms like fatigue and intolerance to cold, as a result. If your resting body is spending less calories, that means you will need to eat even less calories than before to maintain the same weight.

This shutdown mode is obviously counterproductive to achieving weight loss - and even dangerous for your body. Instead of shedding weight during periods of fasting or restriction (which is what most people imagine is happening when they choose not to eat despite being hungry), you are actually just slowing your metabolism down and losing muscle. We were made to survive famine and our body reads starvation or rapid weight loss as an alarm signal, to be fought against at all costs. Under such stressful situations, those stores of fat and every last calorie become precious. However, when the weight loss is slow and progressive, such as in the transition towards intuitive eating, the body is not fighting to survive, it can let go of fat stores knowing that emergency reserves are not needed because the supply is constant and the feeding response to hunger signals is swift. Only in these reassuring circumstances, where every time food is requested it is given and starvation is never a possibility, can your body chill out and do its job property (i.e. maintain your set-point weight).

If you consistently ignore your body’s signals, eventually it might stop talking to you properly. Why would I keep spending energy communicating if she doesn’t respond?, thinks the body. The signals eventually get more and more fuzzy - in some people, they even disappear. Do not let your signals disappear! If they are still there, perhaps too quiet and too confusing for your liking, but still present, consider yourself lucky and pledge right now to listen to them as much as you can, to keep them alive and strong. Remember, they are your boundaries, when to start eating, when to stop eating. If you let them die, there will definitely be no more limit to the amount you can undereat and overeat. Restricting and binging, muscle breakdown and metabolism shutdown then become the de facto state. Concretely, this usually leads to a never ending yo-yo of weight gain and weight loss, commonly known as weight cycling, which has been proven to lead to long term weight gain and disastrous health outcomes.

I won’t go into more details because there’s an excellent book written on this subject by neuroscientist Sandra Aamodt. Why Diets Make You Fat explains how all diets are unnatural and make you fight against your own biology, against your body’s evolutionary survival mechanisms. You can only win this battle temporarily and at great cost. On the long term, your instincts will have the better of you.

No comments:

Post a Comment

My Journey to Intuitive Eating

From Skinny Childhood to Eating Disorder and Back I would like to share my story with you. You who struggle with your weight, food, exer...