Sunday, January 13, 2019

My Journey to Intuitive Eating

From Skinny Childhood to Eating Disorder and Back

I would like to share my story with you. You who struggle with your weight, food, exercise, self-acceptance. I understand how you feel and I may be able to help.

I’ve been thinking about writing this for years but I was held back at first by shame, then by shyness, and then perfectionism. I wanted to find the most impactful way of telling my story so that it would make a big difference in a lot of people’s lives. I haven’t found the perfect way of doing it yet, but I’ve decided to settle for good enough, inspired by every person I encounter (mostly women, but more and more men) who suffer in silence.

I was always a skinny kid who could eat anything, anytime, in any quantity. Growing up, I had insecurities about my body like everyone else, but I never thought about my weight or how much I ate. I didn’t understand how people could get overweight - or worse, obese. I would hear others say it was lack of willpower, so I believed them.

At the beginning of my undergraduate degree, with all the stress that comes with university life, I gained a little bit of weight, especially around the face and belly areas. I didn’t even notice at first, until someone close to me mentioned it. I was shocked. Me, the skinny girl? How could I have let myself get fat! That’s when I started focusing more and more intensely on the bits of my body that had gotten too round and became increasingly insecure about my weight. So I decided to do something about it. But all I knew about losing weight was the lies that society had fed me all my life: control what you eat (you lack discipline!) and go to the gym (you lazy ass!).

I began trying to restrict my portions and blacklisting certain “fattening” foods. I began looking for different ways to “burn off the calories”. It was a very slow and subtle process, seemingly innocent at first, that eventually led to what I now know was a Eating Disorder Not Otherwise Specified or a form of Disordered Eating. I believe many people, especially women, go through the same.

This is how it manifested: I would lash out at my dad when he would serve me too much rice or bread. I refused to buy junk food and banished desserts. I started looking at food labels, pretending not to count calories, but secretly doing so. When I ate out, I scrolled the menu looking for the “healthiest” dish. I was at constant war with my hunger, my cravings, and the food in front of me. I would win one battle and lose five. On a “good” day, I could resist all the tempting fatty foods that I came across, but on a “bad” day I would eat a huge loaf of bread in 2 minutes or a whole bag of cookies until I felt sick… I would undereat then overeat, lose weight then regain it, in a never-ending cycle that left me feeling guilty, ashamed, weak, fat, miserable. I stared at dieting ads and magazines, but never actually went on a diet because I was too proud. I had always considered myself a strong-willed person, achieving any goal I set my mind to. And since I thought eating, too, was under the control of willpower, I couldn’t figure out why I had so little “self-control” in this one area of my life.

It became obsessive. I remember staring at the mirror for hours, hating those love handles, cursing my chunky parts. I remember going to bed disappointed that I had eaten too much or exercised too little, and waking up praying that I would have more “discipline” the next day. I remember taking pictures over and over again until I found an angle where I didn’t look “fat” and deleting all the ones where I did. I felt euphoric when I managed to lose a few pounds, and down in the dumps when I gained them back. Somehow, I managed to not show my distress to anyone. Most people around me never noticed my struggles and I was too ashamed to speak of it. I would fix this problem by myself dammit, if it’s the last thing I do!!

A few years rolled by, my BMI fluctuated below and beyond the overweight mark, maintaining a slow upward trend while my misery deepened. Even though I wasn’t what lot of people would consider fat, I felt fat (and undesirable and insecure) all the time. Until I fell upon a book at a friend’s house one day in 2007: Maigrir sans rĂ©gime (which translates into Losing Weight Without Dieting) by nutritionist and psychotherapist Jean-Philippe Zermati. I poured over it and read 2/3 of the book in one night. Everything he said was unbelievable, yet simple and logical:
  • Dieting or restricting yourself doesn’t work.
  • It puts your body/brain into starvation mode, and will inevitably lead to excess (binge)
  • Your body wants to stay at your predetermined, genetic, healthy weight (set point) and will do everything it can to keep you at that weight.
  • The key is to eat intuitively, listening to your natural signals of hunger and satiation.
  • It has nothing to do with willpower. You cannot fight biology.
I didn’t slim down overnight and instantly become an intuitive eater. It took another few years. Slowly, I starting integrating these notions into my life, with ups and downs. When I re-read the book a second time 3 years later, it really sank in. Since then, I’ve never looked back.

It doesn’t really matter how much weight I lost, but if you must know, it’s probably around 25 pounds, far from the impressive weight losses you see on TV. I’m grateful my eating disorder didn’t spiral out of control and only lasted a few years. Beyond the weight loss though, most importantly, I have made peace with food and with my body (on most days... it’s still a work in progress!). Being free of all the guilt and shame was the biggest blessing. Now, I follow my instincts easily without noticing, I make food choices based on taste (and ethics, but that’s another topic), not on portions and calories and strict rules. I love eating, I love feeling hungry, I love feeling full, I love exercising. None of it has to do with willpower, EVER. My weight on the scale has not varied by even a pound for the last seven years. I’m in the best physical and mental form I have ever been. And I want you, and everyone, to feel the same.

So if you recognize yourself a little or a lot in my story, please read on.

Saturday, January 12, 2019

Is this blog for me?

Do you have food/weight issues?

To answer this, ask yourself these questions:
  • Have you ever dieted?
  • Do you ignore your hunger?
  • Do you have a love-hate relationship with food?
  • Do you feel guilt or shame for eating certain foods?
  • Do you eat beyond fullness?
  • Are there foods you forbid yourself to eat or buy?
  • Do you eat out of stress, boredom, sadness, nervousness?
  • Are you unsatisfied with your body weight?
  • Do you hate looking at yourself in the mirror or in pictures?
  • Do you exercise to “burn off calories”?
  • Are you a “health freak” that chooses carefully every food item?
  • Are you afraid of restaurants and parties because of the risk of overeating?
  • Do you eat a lot of “good” foods to avoid cravings for “bad” foods?
  • Have you ever promised yourself over and over that you will have more control next time, to eat less and to resist temptations?
If you have answered YES to some of the above, you might have food/weight issues or even an Eating Disorder Not Otherwise Specified (EDNOS) or Disordered Eating. You are either a careful eater (stressing about every choice of food), a chronic dieter (always trying out a new diet) or an unconscious eater (often unaware that you’re eating until it’s too late), according to dieticians Tribole & Resch. All of these eating patterns generate a vicious cycle of undereating-overeating (i.e. starvation-binges), which inevitably leads to weight gain and unhappiness. If you’ve had enough, let’s begin to heal and learn to become intuitive eaters.


Beyond Weight Loss

I know, for you who struggle, the only end point that seems to matter is weight loss, as quickly as possible. My arguments about peace with food and your body might not sound very convincing to you. You’ll also be skeptical, and want to see before and after pictures before you’re willing to try out this method that might seem too good to be true. So here are some photos - BUT I’d like to add two disclaimers:
  1. Skinnier is NOT better. It has only been made so by society’s fucked up beauty standards. We all come in different shapes and sizes and we should embrace our bodies for their natural beauty and strength. If I look better in the slimmer version it’s mostly because of the confidence, body positivity and naturalness behind the photo. It’s much harder to look good when you feel ashamed and insecure about your body. Remember, even though you might not believe me right now, becoming skinnier will NOT solve all your problems, nor make you a better, happier person. That comes from somewhere much deeper.
  2. The main goal of intuitive eating is not weight loss, but achieving your natural, genetic weight (which is unique to everyone). If you’re already at this optimal weight and you still wish to lose weight, or if you dream of the perfect Barbie-like body shape, you will forever be unhappy and fight an endless war against your body. Acceptance and self-love are essential in the journey towards healing.
Sorry for the theoretical content in this first post, but it is a necessary introduction to the next, more practical section of my blog. Stay tuned!










Friday, January 11, 2019

Fundamental Principles

How the Body Works
  • In the same way that you have a preset body temperature, you also have a predetermined weight and your body will do everything in its power to maintain that weight. You can call it your “healthy”, “natural” or “genetic” weight. I will use the term set-point.
  • In order to maintain its set-point weight, your body communicates with you through signals of hunger and satiation (indicating the amount of food you need to eat), as well as cravings (indicating the types of food you need to eat).
  • Restriction inevitably leads to excess. If you do not satisfy your hunger, you will feel intense urges to eat compulsively and excessively (i.e. binges).
  • Every time you restrict yourself, you are no longer listening to your body’s signals aka eating instructions (so eventually it stops talking to you properly) and simultaneously, you are sending a dangerous message to your body that food supply is low (so it starts going into starvation mode).
  • When your body is in starvation mode, it will do everything it can to save energy, including breakdown muscle mass and shutdown basal metabolism. You will then “burn” LESS calories at rest and during exercise. At the same time, it will increase its fat stores as protection against the next anticipated episode of starvation.
  • When you lose weight quickly, your body will do everything it can to stop the weight loss. This is a survival mechanism (protection against famines) that you cannot fight.
  • When you lose weight slowly and intuitively, reassuring your body that it will never starve by giving it a constant supply of food at its demand, your body will relax and do its job properly (i.e. maintain your set-point weight).
Do any of these sound counterintuitive, unbelievable, preposterous? Every time I talk about intuitive eating, the first thing everyone says after I finish explaining the basics is: “Oh, that sounds nice but it wouldn’t work for me. I’m different.” The truth is, you are not different - not in this aspect, I mean. We are all different when it comes to shape, height, personality, taste, etc. But our basic physiology and psychology work in the same way. Eating is one of the most fundamental aspects of life and evolution has set up solid mechanisms to regulate it.

If what I say sounds wrong or impossible, it’s probably because you’ve been eating in a non-intuitive and unnatural way for a long time, so many basic mechanisms aren’t functioning optimally. We’ll go over each one of these principles in detail in future posts, so that you understand them better. Feel free to ask questions as we go!

Thursday, January 10, 2019

Homeostasis

Finding Balance

During undergrad, I started out with a major in Physiology and later switched to Biomedical Sciences. One of the first principles we learned in physiology classes was HOMEOSTASIS, defined by dictionary.com as “The tendency of the body to seek and maintain a condition of balance or equilibrium within its internal environment, even when faced with external changes.” What this means is, you have a predetermined biological “set point” (a state of equilibrium) for most physiological functions, and in the presence of outside disruptions your body will always try to bring you back to this set-point.

For example, through complex mechanisms, your body will maintain your internal temperature at around 37°C despite external variations in temperature. When the environment gets too hot, your body sweats to cool down; when it gets too cold, your body shivers to generate some heat. Similarly, your blood sodium levels always stay between 135 and 145 mmol/L no matter how much water or salt you ingest in a day, and will upregulate or downregulate kidney function as well as thirst levels to reach its target. The same goes for the vast majority of physiological processes. Of course, these mechanisms can fail if you overload your body or become sick, but in healthy individuals they work perfectly, without you noticing at all.

Weight is no different, why would it be? You have a predetermined biological weight (set-point) which is unique to each person. A healthy body will consistently try to bring you back to this weight, if you let it. If you gain weight, your body will attempt to help you lose it. If you lose weight, your body will do the opposite. So when all this works properly, weight stays fairly stable over time, at its set-point. It’s been around 7 years since I’ve fully integrated intuitive eating and when I weigh myself for fun once a year, I always get exactly 126lb (57kg) every time. The precision is astounding. When someone is consistently overweight, the vast majority of the time it is not because their body is broken or some illness. It’s because the non-intuitive eater is unwilling or unable to pay attention to their body’s messages - too busy relying on thoughts, beliefs and diet rules - and thereby actively but unwittingly counteracting the body’s attempts to return to set-point. In the wild, animals rely only on their instincts to eat and never become obese (not true for pets and domesticated animals though, because we mess with their instincts). Just like trying to regulate your body temperature or sodium levels using your brain is totally futile and counterproductive, the same is true for weight.

When I explain this, most people will say: “But how can my body know exactly what I need to be healthy? Shouldn’t I exert some kind of control over it to make sure I don’t overeat or indulge on too much junk food?” Well, let’s compare it to breathing. Eating and breathing are absolutely vital for life. Because these functons are so important, they are designed to run smoothly and automatically outside of conscious control. In order words, our body’s physiology is perfectly capable of taking care of itself. Do you ever think about how many breaths you should take a day in order to get enough oxygen for your organs to function? Do you worry that sometimes you will “overbreathe” or “underbreathe” and thus get the wrong oxygen levels? It’s pretty clear that trying to control your breathing is unhelpful for everyday functioning and can even be damageable (i.e. hyperventilation). Therefore, we should start thinking of eating like we think of breathing - a bodily function that works optimally and effortlessly without need for control.

Your body, more than your brain, knows what to do and how to eat to maintain its predetermined weight. It has millions of hormones and neurotransmitters, receptors and processes designed, through millions of years of evolution, to do the job flawlessly. Trust it. This trust is what you have to build along your journey towards intuitive eating. It is essential. Throughout this blog, I will help you learn to trust your body and find homeostasis.

Wednesday, January 9, 2019

Channels of Communication

Your Body’s Talking, Are You Listening?

As mentioned previously, at any given moment in all living organisms, there’s complex communication going on between the cells and organs of the body, relaying important messages for survival. These signals occur well beyond conscious control and do not depend on our awareness to function. They only enter our consciousness when there is the need to change our behaviour to fulfill a basic need, such as eating.

The body is acutely aware of how much food and calories and macronutrients are available and how much more is needed. It will communicate this information to us through signals of hunger (time to eat) and satiation (time to stop eating). More subtly, it can also tell us that we’re low on a specific kind of nutrient by inducing cravings for certain types of foods. However, because the human brain is a powerful machine of central control, it can of course override essential bodily signals and functions. This can be extremely useful (e.g. stopping us from peeing our pants in public) or extremely dangerous (e.g. stopping us from eating to the point of starvation, like in anorexia).


So how do intuitive eaters maintain a stable weight over a long term period? The rule is quite simple: calories in, calories out. If you always eat as much calories as you spend, there will never be any weight gain. All throughout history, humans have known exactly how to do this simply by following their inner signals. Overweight and obesity are new phenomena that arose when the brain started to take over the body’s role. The result is disastrous: as clever as the brain is, it can only keep track of conscious processes, not unconscious ones such as the complex feedback loops involved in metabolism and weight maintenance. Our body is still the world’s most perfect and exact calorie counter.

So how does it work? Basal metabolism, the energy required to keep vital functions going including muscle contraction, breathing and blood flow, uses up most of our energy. And contrary to popular belief, exercise accounts for very little of total energy expenditure, except for very high level athletes. When calories have been spent and energy is low, a web of internal messages kick in and hormones such as ghrelin are secreted to promote feeding behaviour, which in turn is interpreted by the intuitive eater as “I’m hungry”. It is a state of slight discomfort, at first only an itch, a vague sense of emptiness. The only way to calm and neutralise the signal is to eat. If you ignore the message however, it will grow stronger and more insisting. If left unattended, hunger turns to famishment.

I used to be afraid of hunger - it meant the risk of overeating. Hunger felt like a wild, out of control beast that could crush all my food resolutions and shatter any dreams of weight loss. And it’s because it was! Restricting (ignoring my hunger and cravings) meant they never appeared in a discrete and modest form, but always intense and desperate. Now I cherish hunger, I know it simply means I’ve spent my available energy and deserve a good meal to replenish my stocks. Feeling hungry means my body is working properly, and I’m able to read its signals accurately. As I’ve learned to respect and honour these signals, the body’s tyrannical urgings have turned into soft nudgings. Instead of a monster, I now see hunger as my little shoulder angel, guiding me towards the right eating behaviour.

Intuitive eaters who listen to their hunger do not fear excess because there’s always that other signal, satiation, to stop them when they’ve eaten enough. Once enough calories have been ingested and energy levels are replenished, the body secretes a new set of hormones such as leptin that seek to interrupt feeding behaviour. This is interpreted by the intuitive eater as “I’m full”. The body no longer needs any food and tells us so by creating a feeling of satisfaction and completeness, a return to comfort, a relief to the itch created by hunger. This is the state of satiation. If disregarded, overeating (eating past the point of satiation) leads to feeling stuffed, bursting, and even nauseous. This is where weight gain happens.

Hunger is our green light for eating. Satiation is the red light. Together, they give us the precise boundaries between energy depletion and energy restoration, they keep our bodies at set-point weight and homeostasis. The mechanisms are super precise. If these two signals are fully respected, weight can be maintained stable for a lifetime. As kids, most of us were intuitive eaters and we did all of this effortlessly. We didn’t have to think much about what to eat, when and how much. But as adults, we un-learned our instincts and bodily signals, and turned to so-called “knowledge” and “common sense” to direct our feeding behaviours.

This misplaced wisdom has done us wrong, very wrong. We have lost connection with our bodies and attempted to replace its natural signals with artificial norms. Whether we are following unconscious eating rules or strict dieting rules, we are ignoring our hunger and satiation signals and setting ourselves up for trouble. Food labels, apps and calculators can NEVER accurately estimate the amount of calories we ingest and the amount we spend - only our own bodies can do that. Relying on external cues to dictate how we eat means we will always be off, by a small or large margin, and thus our weight will fluctuate according to our miscalculations and the disastrous consequences of repressed hunger and satiation. The next post will detail the phenomena behind dieting (restriction) and binges (excess), and how one inevitably creates the other.

Tuesday, January 8, 2019

Restriction Always Leads to Excess

The Origin of Binges

Previously, we have seen what happens in the mind and body of the intuitive eater who maintains a homeostatic weight by listening carefully to their signals of hunger and satiation. So what happens in the body of the non-intuitive eater?

The vast majority of non-intuitive eaters are in a state of chronic restriction. This does not mean that they are underweight or starving - only that their brain is constantly attempting to override their body. They are never fully relaxed around meals. Most experts call this state cognitive restriction. As such, non-intuitive eaters have one goal - weight loss - and one archenemy - weight gain. Anything that could make them overeat, whether it’s their own hunger, the presence of tempting foods or social contexts that promote eating (e.g. restaurants, parties), is seen as a threat. In short, they are at constant war with food and themselves.

But they’ve devised clever strategies. Non-intuitive eaters have, not always consciously, drawn up lists of allowed (aka non-fattening) foods and forbidden (aka fattening) foods, eating lots of the former in order not to succumb to the latter. If they aren’t on a diet, they have meal plans or portion control to predetermine the quantity of food they will eat at any time, making sure to stick only to allowed foods. They vow not to buy the forbidden foods or order them on the menu. They even go as far as avoiding gatherings and events where there will be too many temptations that could lead to overeating. Typically, Christmas is a dreaded holiday and New Year’s brings its share of weight loss resolutions. Meanwhile, springtime begins with an action plan to fit into summer clothing and ends with “beach body” anxiety.

So do any of the strategies give positive results? You already know the answer: sometimes it works… but never for long. Even when it isn’t actually a diet, all these tactics are forms of cognitive restriction. When you ignore your hunger in an attempt to control your eating, your body believes you’re going through a period of famine, as was common before the modern era. Why else would she not give me the amount of food I want, or the types of food I request?, thinks the body. It then goes into survival mode. The only thing that matters to your body at this point is to increase your food intake, decrease your energy expenditure, and preserve or increase your fat stores - to survive the famine. Because your body is no longer functioning in its normal balanced way, it induces strange behaviours like binges. Why do we binge? It’s a desperate, last resort way of inducing feeding behaviour, when all else has failed.

In response to famine, the body responds initially by sending stronger signals of hunger to make you eat more (i.e. feeling famished) or stronger cravings for the forbidden foods. But when increased motivation to eat does not lead to actual eating, and you continue to deprive yourself of food despite increased hunger and craving signals, the desperate body uses its ultimate weapon and sends you into overdrive - aka binge mode. Binging is the result of increased biological chemicals that overtrigger our eating drive. Instead of moderate hunger and satiation signals that lead to moderate eating, there’s only bottomless frenzied eating. There is an urgent need to eat now, quickly and a lot, as long as food is present, because who knows when there will be another shortage? And of course, the food items with which this happens are inevitably the ones we have deprived ourselves of the most.

No, it’s not you. Binges are not a weakness of character, a lack of discipline, a flaw in your willpower. It’s biology. The more you restrict and forbid, the more your body wants to eat. The only way for binging behaviours to disappear is to eliminate its creator - restriction. Jean-Philippe Zermati, the French nutritionist and psychotherapist who changed my life, used to compare binging to a suitcase filled with a million dollars - imagine the difference in how you would spend the money if I told you it would disappear an hour later versus if I told you it would always be there when you wanted it? Similarly, if you tell your body that whenever it’s hungry, whenever it craves something, you will allow it to eat freely, calm feeding behaviour naturally occurs. Reassured that it will never starve, that there will always be food available, the organism feels safe. However, when food is made scarce through restriction, the body will eat violently as if it had never eaten before, as if it will never eat again. The organism reacts as if the suitcase of food will disappear an hour later. That’s binging. To stop it, you must give the body a suitcase full of food, no locks or passwords, available at any time on demand. In other words, you must give yourself unconditional permission to eat.

My binges peaked midway through undergrad, when I was on an exchange program in Switzerland. On the one hand, I was having the time of my life, meeting amazing people from all around the world and travelling across Europe. On the other hand, I was struggling with food and weight like never before. Living with two roommates, one from Germany and the other from Senegal, I witnessed firsthand what slim, confident, intuitive eaters looked like. Yet I thought that they must be different, that their eating behaviours could not apply to me - clearly, my uncontrollable eating meant I was “broken”. I vividly remember staring at my German roommate while she sat at her desk studying, next to a bookshelf chockfull of Lindt truffles, Ferrero Rochers, Ritter chocolate bars and a variety of candy. Every hour or so, she would reward herself with a tiny piece of sweets, and then go back to her books. This was her daily routine. I can promise you she did not gain a single pound in the year I lived with her, and she had a great body that made me really envious! Meanwhile, from my study desk of carrots and crackers, I could not stop thinking about all the chocolate and candy that taunted me from across the hallway. With shame, I admit today that I frequently stole from her supplies, when the temptation became too strong… Having vowed not to buy any of those forbidden foods myself, I just couldn’t resist them when they were there! The same happened at CafĂ© International, a gathering of international students that I helped organise every week where we served coffee and cookies - I think I must have eaten half the food all to myself. I felt sick afterwards each time.

Had you told me back then that in order to become a stable weight intuitive eater like my roommates, I had to allow myself to freely eat chocolates and cookies, I would have thought you were insane. I would have told you how you clearly didn’t understand my insatiable appetite for these foods and how impossible it was for me to ever eat them moderately. Today, I finally understand that the only reason I acted this way was because of my own cognitive restriction. It actually had nothing to do with failed willpower. UNCONDITIONAL PERMISSION to eat was the key to my release. Scary, I know. You’re thinking “I could never allow myself to eat X food freely, because this food makes me lose control.” X can be chocolate and cookies like me, or it can be fries, pasta, bread, pastries, whatever. You may be tempted into following all my other advice except for this one. But trust me, this is a crucial step towards intuitive eating and set-point weight. If you do not give yourself this permission, you will always be in a state of cognitive restriction, and you will always be at risk of excess. They are two sides of the same coin, one cannot exist without the other. Using restriction to curb excess is getting it the wrong way around - your excesses are born from the seeds of restriction. I cannot explain all the psychological mechanisms behind this subconscious manifestation, but I can promise you that it’s more powerful than any kind of conscious self-control most humans might have.

Being able to eat and enjoy chocolates and cookies peacefully, with no guilt, no remorse, no loss of control and certainly no weight gain is a beautiful gift of living. I wish it upon all of you! In future posts, I will give more practical tips on how to start giving yourself permission and beginning this journey towards freedom.

Monday, January 7, 2019

Further Away from Homeostasis

Other Unnatural Consequences of Restriction

As we have seen, every time you choose to ignore your hunger, i.e. not feed your body when it requires energy and demands food, you are telling your body there is a famine. All forms of diets do this, even the “light” ones, even the ones that promise you won’t go hungry or claim that you can eat what you want. Do not be fooled: in every diet, there’s always obvious or hidden restrictions. We have seen that restriction leads to binges (eating uncontrollably and excessively) as a compensatory response to the periods of restriction. Binges are nothing but an attempt to break the famine, a strategy we can label as “desperately increasing caloric intake”. Another response to intense or prolonged restriction is to save energy at all costs - it’s a “desperately decreasing caloric expenditure” kind of strategy. Let’s see how it works.

When the body’s energy requirements are not met through adequate food intake (i.e. hunger signals are not followed by feeding), the body looks for alternative sources of energy. The most readily available source is the proteins in your muscles. At the same time as your hungry body begins to break down muscle mass, basal metabolism also starts to shut down in order to decrease energy expenditure. On average, most of the calories you burn in one day is just to keep your organs (heart, brain, kidneys) working at rest - this is called basal metabolism. Only a small portion of the total calories spent are due to physical activity. However, when your body starts going into survival mode and shutting everything down to keep energy loss at a strict minimum, it starts guarding every calorie jealously. It won’t let go of any fat, won’t allow any weight loss, because it’s a matter of survival! With a slower metabolism and less muscle mass, you will burn LESS calories than before, whether at rest or during exercise. You may even notice symptoms like fatigue and intolerance to cold, as a result. If your resting body is spending less calories, that means you will need to eat even less calories than before to maintain the same weight.

This shutdown mode is obviously counterproductive to achieving weight loss - and even dangerous for your body. Instead of shedding weight during periods of fasting or restriction (which is what most people imagine is happening when they choose not to eat despite being hungry), you are actually just slowing your metabolism down and losing muscle. We were made to survive famine and our body reads starvation or rapid weight loss as an alarm signal, to be fought against at all costs. Under such stressful situations, those stores of fat and every last calorie become precious. However, when the weight loss is slow and progressive, such as in the transition towards intuitive eating, the body is not fighting to survive, it can let go of fat stores knowing that emergency reserves are not needed because the supply is constant and the feeding response to hunger signals is swift. Only in these reassuring circumstances, where every time food is requested it is given and starvation is never a possibility, can your body chill out and do its job property (i.e. maintain your set-point weight).

If you consistently ignore your body’s signals, eventually it might stop talking to you properly. Why would I keep spending energy communicating if she doesn’t respond?, thinks the body. The signals eventually get more and more fuzzy - in some people, they even disappear. Do not let your signals disappear! If they are still there, perhaps too quiet and too confusing for your liking, but still present, consider yourself lucky and pledge right now to listen to them as much as you can, to keep them alive and strong. Remember, they are your boundaries, when to start eating, when to stop eating. If you let them die, there will definitely be no more limit to the amount you can undereat and overeat. Restricting and binging, muscle breakdown and metabolism shutdown then become the de facto state. Concretely, this usually leads to a never ending yo-yo of weight gain and weight loss, commonly known as weight cycling, which has been proven to lead to long term weight gain and disastrous health outcomes.

I won’t go into more details because there’s an excellent book written on this subject by neuroscientist Sandra Aamodt. Why Diets Make You Fat explains how all diets are unnatural and make you fight against your own biology, against your body’s evolutionary survival mechanisms. You can only win this battle temporarily and at great cost. On the long term, your instincts will have the better of you.

Sunday, January 6, 2019

Do You Forbid Yourself to Eat Certain Foods?

The Myth of Fattening Foods

If you’ve been following the blog for a while, you now understand the importance of listening to your hunger and satiation signals in order for your body to maintain its set-point weight. You know that the opposite (restriction) induces binges and slower metabolism, which inevitably lead to medium-term weight cycling and long-term weight gain. You are now ready to become an intuitive eater. But, you probably still have a hard time believing that the body can do EVERYTHING by itself. Surely it needs the brain to guide it, to help choose between “fattening” and “non-fattening” foods, “healthy” and “unhealthy” foods?

First off, let’s be clear: there’s no such thing as fattening or non-fattening food. Obviously foods vary in calorie density (calorie content per volume or weight). Chocolate has more calories per gram than carrots. BUT eating a piece of chocolate is less fattening than eating a kilogram of carrots! So it’s the total amount of calories that you eat versus spend which will determine your net weight gain or loss, not the food type by itself. No one category of food ever caused anyone to become fat. And if you continue to label foods as good or bad, it will only prevent you from ever becoming an intuitive eater.

One way in which blacklisting foods is counterproductive is the fact that your attempts to replace these foods will always fail - everything else you will eat to mask the craving will never be as satisfying. If you feel like chocolate but instead you eat carrots, you will not satisfy your chocolate craving and will be left with a sensation of emptiness. Your body, discontent, will seek out more. It will eat and eat and eat all the “allowed” foods, in search of the contentment which only the “forbidden” food can provide. In the end, you will definitely overeat. How many times, when craving chocolate, have you eaten a few carrots, felt unsatisfied, then proceeded to eat nuts, and then a fruit... and maybe ended up eating that darn chocolate anyway! What if you had just eaten the piece of chocolate like you wanted to? You’d have ingested less total calories AND felt more content.

This a common problem with non-intuitive eaters. They simply cannot understand how, while restricting so much, while eating only salads and low-calorie foods, they still do not manage to lose any weight! They do not realise that, having given themselves unconditional permission to eat “healthy” foods but without listening to their signals, they consistently overeat them without even noticing, thinking that these allowed foods aren’t fattening anyway. Yes, believe it or not, you can get fat with salads if you ingest more total calories than you spend. (And the opposite is also true: you can stay slim while eating chocolate.) The overeating of allowed foods usually happens in specific circumstances: 1. trying to silence the craving for a forbidden food, 2. trying to eat according to dieting rules or beliefs (such as breakfast is mandatory), 3. trying to eat preventively to appease binge anxiety (e.g. snacking before going to a restaurant or a Christmas dinner, as a way to resist tempting foods). No matter what the reason may be, eating any food in the absence of hunger or beyond satiation inevitably leads to weight gain, whether it’s chocolate or carrots. The distinction between good and bad foods is irrelevant to weight.


The problem is, you can easily eat just one carrot but you cannot eat just one piece of chocolate (or chips or whatever blacklisted “fattening” food)! The very act of forbidding certain foods changed something in your psyche and in the relationship you have with these foods - they become precious, tantalizing, threatening. You may even become obsessed with them and/or crave them all the time. Then when you eventually come across them, your body identifies them as super rare food items and knows that this may be the last opportunity it will ever get to eat them... We have already seen that this is what leads to binges. It’s also important to recognise the emotions that occur during and after the compulsive behaviours: guilt and shame. These deeply negative feelings, instead of helping you achieve your goals, are completely counterproductive and are actually powerful drivers of compulsion. The labelling of “bad” foods and the attempts to shun them means there can never be peace in their presence. The out-of-control, desperate, deprived way in which we eat blacklisted foods does NOT stem from lack of willpower, but is biology and emotion driven. This is how the body and the mind works. When you stop restricting yourself, not only do you stop giving your body incentive to hoard or binge, you eliminate the feelings of guilt and shame that have permeated your relationship with certain types of food - or even food in general. You start to free yourself of the shackles of emotional eating and make your way towards intuitive eating, where needs (communicated through bodily signals) become the main driving forces of feeding behaviours.

Saturday, January 5, 2019

The Tricky Signal: Satiation

Please Do Not Finish Your Plate

We have talked a lot about respecting your hunger and not ever letting yourself starve. But what about that other signal that tells you when to stop eating? For many people, hunger signals are relatively easy to recognise while satiety is a major struggle. Maybe, like me, you’ve been raised with parents who told you to always finish your plate, parents who were allergic to food waste and ranted about poor children not having enough to eat. Or maybe you’ve always thought of yourself as “gluttonous”, a “food lover” that just can’t stop eating. For some, this behaviour takes place at almost every meal, for others it only occurs with certain foods. Either way, eating often feels out of control, and guilt and shame are frequent outcomes. We’ve seen that restricting and blacklisting food types were two of the main causes, but let’s also talk about how other mislead beliefs can lead to counterproductive and harmful eating behaviours.

Where did the silly idea that you must always finish your plate come from? People justify this in all sorts of ways: respect for the cook, waste reduction, empathy for starving children, etc. But think about it for a second: is it really possible that your plate ALWAYS contains EXACTLY the quantity of food that you need in that precise moment? Of course not! Your plate is far more likely to be too small or too big, rather than just perfect. Your body however, as we’ve seen, knows by extremely precise mechanisms how much it needs to maintain homeostasis, and the signals it sends you are the only reliable indicators of when to continue or when to stop eating. The boundaries of eating should therefore not be determined by the size of the portion or the plate, but by the hunger and satiation signals at work. Once you’ve become an intuitive eater, it should be very surprising if you come to feel perfectly full after eating exactly the amount that was served. Most of the time, you should be either helping yourself to some more or leaving food behind, ending each meal physically and psychologically content.

Remember: everything you eat while hungry and BEFORE the point of fullness will be used to rebuild depleted stores and for upcoming energy expenditure. No matter the food type, or the total quantity, none of the food eaten before satiation will ever be “fattening”. On the other hand, everything you eat AFTER the point of fullness will likely be stored away for future use and contribute to weight gain. At satiation, tell your host it was a lovely meal and that you’re sorry you can’t finish because you’re full. No one will be offended. Do not look at how much everyone else ate, whether you ate more or less than average, because each person has completely different caloric needs (which cannot be judged by appearance). In order to reduce waste, ask for a doggy bag at the restaurant or store your leftovers at home for another meal. Unfortunately, contrary to what parents say, starving children elsewhere around the world will not benefit from your overeating.

As for the belief that gluttony or weakness are to blame for your inability to stop at satiation, nothing could be further from the truth. I have said this many times before but I will repeat it again: there are powerful biological and psychological drives behind this kind of behaviour and it has NOTHING to do with lack of willpower or personality, or whatever other oversimplified explanation. If you are consistently eating what you want in exactly the quantity that your body needs, it’s very easy to stop yourself when full. There will be a natural calmness and satisfaction that will come over you telling you you’ve had enough, knowing that you are always well fed, that you can come back for more later. On the other hand, if you are eating in the absence of hunger or desire, only for the sake of health or weight loss, or in a state of famine, or to calm cravings for forbidden foods, you will never feel the natural satisfaction that comes with real satiation. Inevitably, you will end up overeating to compensate for the lack of contentment. Only by giving yourself unconditional permission to eat can you let go of those impulses to “eat the whole bag”. Once you’ve proven to your body that it needs not prepare for starvation, that it can have as much as it wants anytime it’s hungry, the need to finish it all, the urge to eat everything out of fear of future deprivation, will disappear progressively.

People sometimes ask me how I recognise my satiation, and it’s hard to explain because it’s quite an abstract feeling. Contrary to what many non-intuitive eaters believe, it has nothing to do with a loaded stomach (or gastric distension, in scientific terms) - that’s actually a sign of overeating! When you’ve ignored your satiation signals for too long, they become difficult to recognise and all you feel is gastric distension, which becomes the (wrong) cue to stop eating. This is a common cause of weight gain. Real satiation is more of a state of stillness and peacefulness. There is physical and psychological satisfaction. The feeling of a job well done, a duty accomplished, a need fulfilled. It could be likened to the contentment felt after quenching your thirst, or the state of relief that comes after scratching an itch, or a breeze of fresh air after feeling hot.

The best way to recognise comfortable fullness before feeling stuffed is to eat slowly and mindfully. Each bite should be enjoyed: the look, the smell, the taste, the texture, the aftertaste… Throughout the meal, you should pay attention to levels of satiation as they grow: as much the feeling in your body as the psychological satisfaction. At the beginning of the process of intuitive eating, you might have to be hyper vigilant and check in on your body signals frequently and attentively. But with time, this will become so natural you won’t even have to think about it. Just like when you learned to drive, at the beginning you had to consciously hold the wheel, look at the mirrors, change the gear, adjust your feet, but eventually all these things are done without conscious thought.

I used to roll my eyes at intuitive eaters who would leave a couple of mouthfuls in their plate, claiming they were too full to finish. Come on, what a waste! Just make a little effort!, was always my judgement of them. Now I understand. As your intuitive eating becomes stronger, not only will it be easy and thoughtless to recognise satiation, but it will also become difficult to ingest anything once you’re full. Trying to finish your plate when you’re no longer hungry will one day feel hard, oppressive and even painful!

Friday, January 4, 2019

So What's Wrong with Trying to Be Healthy?

Intuitive Eating Before Healthy Eating

When I said in a previous post that I wanted you to be able to eat cookies and chips as you please, I’m sure many of you immediately thought “but, what about health?”. Isn’t it ok to want to avoid cookies and chips because they are unhealthy? So let’s talk about that. I am, after all, a doctor, and obviously concerned with health. While modern society is incredibly unhealthy in so many ways, it is also health crazy in other ways, which is just as harmful. Excessive preoccupation with healthy eating has become so widespread that a new term was coined in 1997 to describe the phenomenon - orthorexia. The idea came from U.S. doctor Steven Bratman who suggested, according to Wikipedia, “that some people’s dietary restrictions intended to promote health may paradoxically lead to unhealthy consequences, such as social isolation, anxiety, loss of ability to eat in a natural, intuitive manner, reduced interest in the full range of other healthy human activities, and, in rare cases, severe malnutrition or even death.”

Many non-intuitive eaters, the ones we described in a previous article as “careful eaters”, fit the description of orthorexia, whether in its milder or more severe forms. Their cognitive restriction has lead to a real obsession with calories, sugar and fat content, meal planning, physical activity and other forms of weight control. Under the guise of “concern for health”, their problematic behaviours go unrecognised, or worse, are applauded by their family and friends. As long as the objective includes the word “health”, it immediately elicits a positive reaction by society. While healthy eating has become a moral standard to aspire to, a supreme way of living for the most virtuous among us, sadly it is most of the time another form of dieting, sending millions of people into harmful restriction. But since health obsession has become so commonplace, it is no wonder so many people suffer from severe eating disorders for years without anyone ever noticing!

Previous posts have explained how labelling foods as “healthy” or “unhealthy” - which falls right into the current trend towards generalised societal orthorexia - is counterproductive to weight and health, leading to overeating, emotional eating, intense cravings and binges. We have turned eating, a natural and instinctive process, into a military and moral duty, to be scrutinised and judged according to the latest health fad. Not only does it ruin the hedonic part of eating, but it has also caused anxiety and guilt around food choices and meal preparations. The truth is, having dessert or fries once in a while IS healthy. What isn’t healthy is obsession, deprivation and binges as a result of health neurosis. We need to become less preoccupied with the health rating of individual meals, and more concerned with how we relate to our food.

That is why I insist so much on leaving health out of the equation in the first phases of the transition to intuitive eating. The first and most crucial step is to heal your relationship with food. You can never eat healthy and be healthy if you feel deprived or out of control, if you hate your body and go through constant weight cycling, which as mentioned previously leads to distrastrous health consequences. Recall the concept of play foods (term that replaces the more negative label, junk food). When mealtime is an enjoyable activity and food is a friend, you naturally and effortlessly go for the healthy stuff most of the time, and play foods occasionally. Instead, when mealtime is war and food is the enemy, healthy foods are a punishment and a burden while play foods become the escape, the solace, the comfort and the catharsis. A stressed, weakened body that has been bullied into silence or submission by diets and restrictive rules, cannot make healthy decisions. A person in cognitive restriction who constantly eats in an all-or-none fashion cannot make healthy choices. They are at the mercy of their impulses. Impulses which are born, not from the lack of willpower, but from powerful biological and psychological drives induced by restriction, as we have seen.

If you believe that you cannot possibly allow yourself to eat freely and intuitively because you are sure you would choose play foods all the time, rest assured that I thought the same, and everyone else too who started their journey towards intuitive eating. I was convinced that freeing myself to eat forbidden foods would turn me into an unhealthy, insatiable cookie monster, a bottomless barrel for chocolate and bread. Until I realised that what I thought was gluttony and lack of self-control was just in fact a state of chronic restriction. When that state lifts, the forbidden play foods no longer hold their appeal. One cookie or half a chocolate bar becomes satisfying and sufficient. Veggies and fruits and all the healthy stuff are no longer fillers or substitutes, but loved foods that are craved as much as, and even more so, than the fat and sugary stuff. That is the way nature intended the body to work - to crave and seek the foods that nourish it the best. Animals in the wild do not have to force themselves to pick healthy foods, they instinctively want to eat them. Similarly, when you listen properly to your body, it will guide you to eat according to your needs (caloric and nutritional) without any coercion or rationalisation. It even creates some extra room for CHOICE, where health becomes just one of many criteria (like hunger level, desire, taste, ethics, etc.) upon which you will base your food choices.

In short, once you have given yourself unconditional permission to eat, once there are no more forbidden foods and all items can be eaten peacefully, only then can it be possible for you to make “healthy choices”. You can choose whole wheat instead of white bread, veggie burgers instead of beef burgers, fruit instead of candy - without feeling deprived or frustrated, without trying to hide cravings for something else, without trying to suppress hunger or eat preventively. And you will also be able to eat your cake once in a while without any feelings of guilt. In a state of restriction, it is simply not possible to “eat healthy” without some form of psychological damage and negative spiralling. If you’re not yet an intuitive eater, be very wary of the health propaganda out there and focus on listening to your body and letting yourself eat unconditionally first and foremost. Avoiding the restrictive health labels is absolutely essential if you wish to reach, at the end of this journey, a place of homeostasis where maintaining set-point weight and making healthy choices demands no effort.

Thursday, January 3, 2019

Forget the Gym!

Why Exercise is Not a Weight Loss Solution

Of course exercise is great for physical and mental health. But no matter what the fitness industry tries to sell, it is NOT a sustainable weight loss method, according to the best scientific evidence. As explained before, most of the calories you spend are used up by your metabolism. Only a small amount is actually spent during exercise (unless you’re a high-level athlete). All the calories you think you burnt at the gym or on that jog are easily undone by just one meal where you overeat. As you now know, non-intuitive eating means your feeding behaviour does not match your caloric needs, and therefore frequent out-of-control eating will erase or even counteract the effects of increased caloric expenditure achieved through physical activity. Here’s a great video that explains the concept. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eXTiiz99p9o

Since food intake has the most influence on weight, you must solve your food issues if you ever hope to achieve durable weight loss and long-term set-point weight maintenance. No amount of physical activity can make up for the absence of intuitive eating. Physical activity also tends to increase hunger levels because of increased caloric expenditure, so non-intuitive eaters will sometimes feel even more out-of-control in front of food after exercise. Intuitive eating means adjusting calorie input, which is done effortlessly and precisely by following hunger and satiety signals; whereas compensatory exercise means adjusting caloric output, which is extremely hard and frequently ineffective for all the reasons mentioned above (and as many of you have probably already experienced for yourselves).

Unfortunately, exercise regimes have become increasingly popular as another form of dieting or purging. People submit themselves to gruelling programs, thinking that every hour spent exercising is burning off fat. Others use it after binges or “bad weeks” to compensate for overeating. All this has made exercise lose its main purpose: making you feel good now and making you healthy in the long term. Moving the body is natural - I would even say it is a fundamental human need and contributes largely to happiness and health. Every kid is born with the love to jump, run and play. But as we grow into adults, the universal instinct to move becomes regimented into exercise and fitness, with a set of rules and pragmatic objectives. For the non-intuitive eaters, it has literally been turned into a burden or a punishment. No wonder you can’t get your butt to the gym! Again, you will blame your low motivation on lack of willpower, when in fact it is because you have turned physical activity into a chore rather than a source of enjoyment.

I certainly failed miserably at achieving my previous weight loss goals through exercise. I was a very sedentary kid - watching TV and reading books were my favourite passtimes! My high school gym teacher, a total bully, destroyed any inclination for sports I might have felt. But when I began spiralling into my eating disorder, I started working out more than I ever had in my life - this included two hour sessions in my bedroom before going to bed, running up and down the stairs to school or work, jogging in the middle of the night (and I absolutely HATED running!), etc. None of it helped me achieve sustainable weight loss. At the peak of my exercise mania, I was heavier than I had ever been. It was certainly not like in the ads where people smile through their sweat from the satisfaction of a good workout - mine were acts of desperation. Seized with panick after a day of overeating, or mirror-staring body-hating sessions, or not being able to fit in old clothes, I worked out with a sense of dread and fear of becoming fat. But this sense of urgency only appeared once in a while - the rest of the time, when it came to planning for exercise, I was seized with instant feelings of lethargy and disinterest. Instead of feeling motivated and inspired, I was looking for any excuse not to do it. I used to admire people who had the “discipline” to work out everyday and seemed to enjoy it. Why was I so weak willed and lazy? I never thought that, if I shifted paradigms and focused on how awesome moving my body made me feel, I could actually find activities that I loved so much that I would WANT to do them every day, and crave it when I skipped it! When I finally realised that the pressure I put on myself to exercise in the hopes of shedding pounds was what killed any innate desire to move, I finally freed up some energy and mental space to find my real passions which, after years of daily or weekly practice, still keep me happy and fit to this day: cycling, yoga and dance!

So by all means, please be active, but for the sake of pleasure, not weight loss. And if achieving your set-point weight is your priority right now, focus on intuitive eating rather than exercise.

Wednesday, January 2, 2019

Trust and Pleasure

Eating is Intrinsically Emotional

This is the last but probably the most important theoretical concept in this blog. We’ve talked a lot about the physical, but we need to delve deeper into the emotional processes behind intuitive eating. Without learning more about trust and pleasure, we cannot move forward.


Every diet, every restriction, teaches you not to trust your body, not to trust food. You see yourself going from one extreme to another, losing control, feeling up and down. Your inability to achieve the goal of weight loss or weight maintenance leaves you feeling like a failure. But what has failed you is the dieting mentality and its lies, not your willpower. When you no longer listen to your body, you become more reliant on external sources to guide your eating: what’s available in front of you, levels of stress, marketing, etc. The more you are in tune with your body signals, the less vulnerable to “externally-directed” eating you become. Intuitive eating implies trust in your body, and this can be very difficult if you’ve lost it a long time ago. You may even think it’s impossible. But I’ve read about people who dieted up to the age of 60 and were finally able to reconnect with their hunger and satiety signals despite decades of mistrust. So I’m sure you can do it too.

So many people I talk to think that this method won’t work for them because they’re different, or too far gone, or too gluttonous. That’s just not true. The only people for whom Intuitive Eating doesn’t work are those who never really rekindle the trust with their body signals and never really let go of their restrictions. The ones who only give “pseudo-permission” to their body to become the leader of their eating behaviour, rather than unconditional permission. If you learn to give yourself this unconditional permission, you can learn to eat intuitively, lose weight (if you’re above your set-point) and find peace. Remember, we were all born intuitive eaters, it’s in our nature. There are no records of overweight wild animals because of all of them are intuitive eaters, as we are. They use instincts, never brains, to decide when to eat, what to eat, and how much.

Finally, we must also talk about pleasure, because food has been and always will be a hedonic activity. Pleasure is such an important part of life and eating, yet we often ignore it for the sake of weight loss and “nutrition”! Some people even feel that they don’t deserve to eat certain foods because they’re overweight. When eating is dissociated with pleasure, it becomes a chore - or even worse, a war. No peace can be found on a battleground. But satisfying your “psychological” hunger (in the sense of getting pleasure from your food) is as vital as satisfying your physical hunger. Eating carrots when you wanted chocolate will leave you feeling discontent and looking for something else. In the end, it will lead you to overeat. That’s why cravings and tastebuds are also important to listen to when you choose what you’re going to eat next. So strive to feel satisfied with what you eat, it will help prevent overeating!

On the road to becoming an intuitive eater, you will notice that every food item that you eat brings you a certain amount of pleasure that is finite, and same goes for the overall meal. Why does the first bite always taste better than the last? Let’s call it food saturation. There’s general food saturation and food-specific saturation. So every food item follows a decreasing curve, where the first bites are the best and the following bites are less and less satisfying. When you are aware of your senses and pay attention to your body signals, it’s pretty easy to tell when you’ve had enough of something (when you’ve reached food-specific saturation) and that soup or salad no longer provides any pleasure. That’s when it’s time to stop eating the food item, no matter how much is left in your plate, and move on to the next course, if you’ve not yet reached general saturation. Having variety in your plate obviously makes eating more enjoyable as there’s less of each food, so it takes longer to get tired of the general meal. This food-specific saturation phenomenon explains why we can be “full” for one food and still “hungry” for another. Contrary to what most people think, being unable to finish your main course but still having room for dessert is possible and even common. (No, it’s not just kid manipulation techniques!) Finally, it’s only when general saturation (satiation) is attained that the meal is over. You are no longer hungry for anything, and it’s time to stop eating. Again, this does not depend on what’s left in the plate, but only on your body signals. The feeling can be vague if you’ve ignored your signals for a long time, but one day it will be come very clear, as it is for intuitive eaters.

But what if “desire” comes in conflict with “satiety”? What if I still crave that chocolate even when I’m already full? It’s a complex issue. First, if you’re not yet an intuitive eater, the presence of cravings in the absence of hunger are probably residual symptoms of your restrictions. You’re still not giving yourself full permission to eat everything, you’re still hanging on to the belief that you must control what you eat, and that some unhealthy foods should be abstained from. In that case, you can’t fool your body: it will still think that calories are scarce, that it could starve tomorrow, that the food it wants might be taken away at anytime. It reacts by wanting to stock up in fear of future deprivation. Second, this could be a sign of emotional eating. Chocolate might be a comfort food - and even though your physical hunger has been quenched, your emotional needs are not fully met and you seek to appease yourself with food. But unfortunately, eating chocolate will not solve your emotional issues. It will probably even make it worse, because you will overeat and then feel ashamed of overeating, therefore increasing emotional distress. The only way out is to deal with the negative emotions that are leading you to eat without hunger in the first place, and instead turn to self-help, meditation, therapy, and other forms of healing.

That being said, there are days when you just want to eat that chocolate even though you’re full! No hidden restrictions, no hidden distress. That’s totally ok! Once you become an intuitive eater, most of the time you will respect your hunger and satiation. But not all the time! The perfect intuitive eater does not exist! But on the rare occasions that you didn’t listen to you signals, it won’t matter because your intuitive body will eventually restore balance. We all have times when we’re so busy we skip a meal, or when we over-indulge during Christmas dinner because the food is just insanely good. No need to panic. When you trust your body to lead the way, you know that these are exceptions to the rule, and your body will naturally compensate by eating more or less at the next meal - without you having to think about it at all! Studies show that intuitive eaters naturally adjust their caloric intake according to the previous meal’s calories, without even knowing it - restricted eaters cannot do this. Intuitive eaters are also able to maintain a very stable weight even when consuming a highly variable amount of calories each day, because it balances out over the long term. Remember, it’s what you eat regularly that matters, not what you eat at a few family parties! One meal does not make or break you.

Tuesday, January 1, 2019

The End and the Beginning

A Summary of Key Concepts

1. Diets don’t work. Commit right now to never again go on a diet or a meal plan (or anything that vaguely resembles either). No matter how much weight your friend lost with so-and-so method, no matter how sensible that new diet seems, no matter how many health professionals recommended that “healthy eating” program. You now know that there are only two possible outcomes to restriction: neverending rollercoaster rides with your weight, with harmful consequences on your health and inevitable weight gain in the long run OR a constant state of watchfulness and inhibition without the possibility of relaxing around a meal and fully enjoying what you crave. Remember that diets will not help you achieve your ultimate goals, the most important of which are happiness and satisfaction.
Have you just heard about a new way of eating that claims to be non-restrictive? Apparently you are allowed to eat what you want, even bad foods! Seems too good to be true, right? Well, it probably is. Any method that tells you in some way when to start eating, when to stop eating, how much and what types of food to eat, is a form of dieting. It lures you away from your bodily signals, and into a world of thoughts, calculations and/or rules, no matter how “relaxed” they might seem. If it’s not intuitive, then it’s restrictive.
2. Every time you fail to respond to your hunger, you are sending your body into a state of famine. It reacts by going into energy saving mode. Instead of helping you lose weight, this will trigger a vicious cycle of muscle breakdown, decreased basal metabolism and increased fat stores. Therefore, ALWAYS eat when you’re hungry, to reassure your body that it will never run out of food and keep it running at full speed without storing fat.
Do you imagine that each minute of not eating while you’re hungry is burning away fat stores? If so, you’re completely mistaken! Instead, each minute of not eating is sending signals of scarcity to your body which encourages it to store fat and slow down metabolism to prevent starvation. When the body is afraid it will not be fed, it feels the need to jealously guard each calorie. So always eat when you’re hungry: tell your body it’s safe to let go of fat stores because you will never let it starve. Keep the fire burning with a steady supply of wood!
3. Overeating has nothing to do with portion size or food types - quantity should be dictated only by your hunger level, and the type of food by your taste and cravings. Overeating is simply eating when you’re not hungry or already full. Any food - even fruits and veggies - eaten in the absence of hunger or beyond satiation is excess energy that your body doesn’t need. Unless this energy is used up, it will be stored in the form of fat. On the other hand, eating while hungry will NEVER lead to weight gain as it’s simply replenishing the energy that was spent and that’s needed for essential body functions.
Imagine that hunger is the flashing light that indicates the gas tank is empty, and food is the fuel. Every bite you eat is filling up the tank and increasing your energy levels and capacity to function properly. Tank sizes very between individuals (Michael Phelps ingests over ten thousand calories a day!) and tank levels also vary within a single individual depending on previous mileage (energy expenditure = basal metabolism + physical activity). Apps, calculators and your brain have no idea how many calories you spent and how much you should eat. Only your body knows this. You are notified of an empty tank by your hunger signals and of a full tank by your satiation signals. So before starting to eat, ask yourself “Am I really hungry” (is my tank really empty)? Pause a few times during the meal to keep checking on yourself. “Am I STILL hungry?” (does my tank still need filling?). I find it useful to have a glass of water on the side and take drinking breaks to check in on my body. You should stop when you feel physically and psychologically satisfied (ah yes, my tank is full!), and be alert to signs that you are about to overeat (oops, overflowing tank!).
4. Do not ban any foods, even “unhealthy” ones from your diet - except for medical or ethical reasons (e.g allergies, veganism). I am myself a long-term committed vegan, but I do not recommend going 100% plant-based before solving weight/food issues. Banning any kind of food items when you’re still struggling with cognitive restriction will simply make forbidden foods more alluring and promote overeating of other replacement foods.
Any food that you crave, eat it! Don’t try to replace it with something else that you consider better but less appetizing. While eating it, enjoy every bite of it and tell yourself “It’s ok, eating this once in a while will not make me unhealthy or fat or a bad person. Forbidding myself to eat it will only make things worse. I can have as much as I want, as long as I’m hungry, and I can even come back to it later if I want more.”

CONGRATULATIONS, YOU ARE NOW AN INTUITIVE EATER (ALMOST)!

If you are able to integrate these concepts into your life, you will feel your body and mind slowly change over time. You might not notice much change at the beginning, but I promise that you will look back in a few years and be amazed by the transformation. And you will never want to go back. I can honestly say, it is one of the most liberating changes I have made in my life and I am eternally grateful to all the authors/mentors that have put me on this path. My next post - the final one on this blog - will include useful and inspirational quotes from the books that have changed my life. Thanks for reading until here and feel free to reach out for any additional advice!

My Journey to Intuitive Eating

From Skinny Childhood to Eating Disorder and Back I would like to share my story with you. You who struggle with your weight, food, exer...