Intuitive Eating Before Healthy Eating
When I said in a previous post that I wanted you to be able to eat cookies and chips as you please, I’m sure many of you immediately thought “but, what about health?”. Isn’t it ok to want to avoid cookies and chips because they are unhealthy? So let’s talk about that. I am, after all, a doctor, and obviously concerned with health. While modern society is incredibly unhealthy in so many ways, it is also health crazy in other ways, which is just as harmful. Excessive preoccupation with healthy eating has become so widespread that a new term was coined in 1997 to describe the phenomenon - orthorexia. The idea came from U.S. doctor Steven Bratman who suggested, according to Wikipedia, “that some people’s dietary restrictions intended to promote health may paradoxically lead to unhealthy consequences, such as social isolation, anxiety, loss of ability to eat in a natural, intuitive manner, reduced interest in the full range of other healthy human activities, and, in rare cases, severe malnutrition or even death.”
Many non-intuitive eaters, the ones we described in a previous article as “careful eaters”, fit the description of orthorexia, whether in its milder or more severe forms. Their cognitive restriction has lead to a real obsession with calories, sugar and fat content, meal planning, physical activity and other forms of weight control. Under the guise of “concern for health”, their problematic behaviours go unrecognised, or worse, are applauded by their family and friends. As long as the objective includes the word “health”, it immediately elicits a positive reaction by society. While healthy eating has become a moral standard to aspire to, a supreme way of living for the most virtuous among us, sadly it is most of the time another form of dieting, sending millions of people into harmful restriction. But since health obsession has become so commonplace, it is no wonder so many people suffer from severe eating disorders for years without anyone ever noticing!
Previous posts have explained how labelling foods as “healthy” or “unhealthy” - which falls right into the current trend towards generalised societal orthorexia - is counterproductive to weight and health, leading to overeating, emotional eating, intense cravings and binges. We have turned eating, a natural and instinctive process, into a military and moral duty, to be scrutinised
and judged according to the latest health fad. Not only does it ruin the hedonic part of eating, but it has also caused anxiety and guilt around food choices and meal preparations. The truth is, having dessert
or fries once in a while IS healthy. What isn’t healthy is obsession,
deprivation and binges as a result of health neurosis. We need to become less preoccupied with the health rating of individual meals, and more concerned with how we relate to our food.
That is why I insist so much on leaving health out of the equation in the first phases of the transition to intuitive eating. The first and most crucial step is to heal your relationship with food. You can never eat healthy and be healthy if you feel deprived or out of control, if you hate your body and go through constant weight cycling, which as mentioned previously leads to distrastrous health consequences. Recall the concept of play foods (term that replaces the more negative label, junk food). When mealtime is an enjoyable activity and food is a friend, you naturally and effortlessly go for the healthy stuff most of the time, and play foods occasionally. Instead, when mealtime is war and food is the enemy, healthy foods are a punishment and a burden while play foods become the escape, the solace, the comfort and the catharsis. A stressed, weakened body that has been bullied into silence or submission by diets and restrictive rules, cannot make healthy decisions. A person in cognitive restriction who constantly eats in an all-or-none fashion cannot make healthy choices. They are at the mercy of their impulses. Impulses which are born, not from the lack of willpower, but from powerful biological and psychological drives induced by restriction, as we have seen.
If you believe that you cannot possibly allow yourself to eat freely and intuitively because you are sure you would choose play foods all the time, rest assured that I thought the same, and everyone else too who started their journey towards intuitive eating. I was convinced that freeing myself to eat forbidden foods would turn me into an unhealthy, insatiable cookie monster, a bottomless barrel for chocolate and bread. Until I realised that what I thought was gluttony and lack of self-control was just in fact a state of chronic restriction. When that state lifts, the forbidden play foods no longer hold their appeal. One cookie or half a chocolate bar becomes satisfying and sufficient. Veggies and fruits and all the healthy stuff are no longer fillers or substitutes, but loved foods that are craved as much as, and even more so, than the fat and sugary stuff. That is the way nature intended the body to work - to crave and seek the
foods that nourish it the best. Animals in the wild do not have to
force themselves to pick healthy foods, they instinctively want to eat
them. Similarly, when you listen properly to your body, it will guide
you to eat according to your needs (caloric and nutritional) without any
coercion or rationalisation. It even creates some extra room for CHOICE, where health becomes just one of many criteria (like hunger level, desire, taste, ethics, etc.) upon which you will base your food choices.
In short, once you have given yourself unconditional permission to eat, once there are no more forbidden foods and all items can be eaten peacefully, only then can it be possible for you to make “healthy choices”. You can choose whole wheat instead of white bread, veggie burgers instead of beef burgers, fruit instead of candy - without feeling deprived or frustrated, without trying to hide cravings for something else, without trying to suppress hunger or eat preventively. And you will also be able to eat your cake once in a while without any feelings of guilt. In a state of restriction, it is simply not possible to “eat healthy” without some form of psychological damage and negative spiralling. If you’re not yet an intuitive eater, be very wary of the health propaganda out there and focus on listening to your body and letting yourself eat unconditionally first and foremost. Avoiding the restrictive health labels is absolutely essential if you wish to reach, at the end of this journey, a place of homeostasis where maintaining set-point weight and making healthy choices demands no effort.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
My Journey to Intuitive Eating
From Skinny Childhood to Eating Disorder and Back I would like to share my story with you. You who struggle with your weight, food, exer...
-
Please Do Not Finish Your Plate We have talked a lot about respecting your hunger and not ever letting yourself starve. But what about th...
-
From Skinny Childhood to Eating Disorder and Back I would like to share my story with you. You who struggle with your weight, food, exer...
-
Finding Balance During undergrad, I started out with a major in Physiology and later switched to Biomedical Sciences. One of the first pri...

No comments:
Post a Comment