Of course exercise is great for physical and mental health. But no matter what the fitness industry tries to sell, it is NOT a sustainable weight loss method, according to the best scientific evidence. As explained before, most of the calories you spend are used up by your metabolism. Only a small amount is actually spent during exercise (unless you’re a high-level athlete). All the calories you think you burnt at the gym or on that jog are easily undone by just one meal where you overeat. As you now know, non-intuitive eating means your feeding behaviour does not match your caloric needs, and therefore frequent out-of-control eating will erase or even counteract the effects of increased caloric expenditure achieved through physical activity. Here’s a great video that explains the concept. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eXTiiz99p9o
Since food intake has the most influence on weight, you must solve your food issues if you ever hope to achieve durable weight loss and long-term set-point weight maintenance. No amount of physical activity can make up for the absence of intuitive eating. Physical activity also tends to increase hunger levels because of increased caloric expenditure, so non-intuitive eaters will sometimes feel even more out-of-control in front of food after exercise. Intuitive eating means adjusting calorie input, which is done effortlessly and precisely by following hunger and satiety signals; whereas compensatory exercise means adjusting caloric output, which is extremely hard and frequently ineffective for all the reasons mentioned above (and as many of you have probably already experienced for yourselves).
Unfortunately, exercise regimes have become increasingly popular as another form of dieting or purging. People submit themselves to gruelling programs, thinking that every hour spent exercising is burning off fat. Others use it after binges or “bad weeks” to compensate for overeating. All this has made exercise lose its main purpose: making you feel good now and making you healthy in the long term. Moving the body is natural - I would even say it is a fundamental human need and contributes largely to happiness and health. Every kid is born with the love to jump, run and play. But as we grow into adults, the universal instinct to move becomes regimented into exercise and fitness, with a set of rules and pragmatic objectives. For the non-intuitive eaters, it has literally been turned into a burden or a punishment. No wonder you can’t get your butt to the gym! Again, you will blame your low motivation on lack of willpower, when in fact it is because you have turned physical activity into a chore rather than a source of enjoyment.I certainly failed miserably at achieving my previous weight loss goals through exercise. I was a very sedentary kid - watching TV and reading books were my favourite passtimes! My high school gym teacher, a total bully, destroyed any inclination for sports I might have felt. But when I began spiralling into my eating disorder, I started working out more than I ever had in my life - this included two hour sessions in my bedroom before going to bed, running up and down the stairs to school or work, jogging in the middle of the night (and I absolutely HATED running!), etc. None of it helped me achieve sustainable weight loss. At the peak of my exercise mania, I was heavier than I had ever been. It was certainly not like in the ads where people smile through their sweat from the satisfaction of a good workout - mine were acts of desperation. Seized with panick after a day of overeating, or mirror-staring body-hating sessions, or not being able to fit in old clothes, I worked out with a sense of dread and fear of becoming fat. But this sense of urgency only appeared once in a while - the rest of the time, when it came to planning for exercise, I was seized with instant feelings of lethargy and disinterest. Instead of feeling motivated and inspired, I was looking for any excuse not to do it. I used to admire people who had the “discipline” to work out everyday and seemed to enjoy it. Why was I so weak willed and lazy? I never thought that, if I shifted paradigms and focused on how awesome moving my body made me feel, I could actually find activities that I loved so much that I would WANT to do them every day, and crave it when I skipped it! When I finally realised that the pressure I put on myself to exercise in the hopes of shedding pounds was what killed any innate desire to move, I finally freed up some energy and mental space to find my real passions which, after years of daily or weekly practice, still keep me happy and fit to this day: cycling, yoga and dance!
So by all means, please be active, but for the sake of pleasure, not weight loss. And if achieving your set-point weight is your priority right now, focus on intuitive eating rather than exercise.
No comments:
Post a Comment